Help Neil and Karen meet an urgent £8,000 legal costs demand
Neil McDougall and Karen Churchill are facing an £8,000 demand arising from their UK legal challenges over telecoms mast siting decisions. They are still disputing who should bear those costs and need help meeting the demand.
£10,000 of the current gofundme has been raised since September 2023 and has funded critical fees and expenses in campaigning to date. The crowdfund target has now been raised to £18k.
If you can contribute, please donate using the link below. Sharing the appeal will also help it to reach people who want clear accountability for mast siting decisions.
https://www.gofundme.com/f/admin-fees-for-litigants-in-person
Neil and Karen have been arguing since 2023 that local planning authorities have a legal responsibility to assess site-specific evidence before approving where a mast goes.
In August 2026, they filed an application with the European Court of Human Rights. They hope that the Court can help open a route to a friendly settlement with the UK Government that resolves these issues without further contested proceedings.
To cite a current example of why clarity on the responsibility held by duty holders matters: At Thomas Way in Glastonbury (2026/1478/TEL), the approved mast would stand beside around 150 steel shipping containers. Residents submitted evidence that reflections from the containers could increase exposure in parts of the yard used by customers and workers. Neil and Karen argue that this was a material land-use issue under NPPF policy DM7(1) and that Somerset needed to assess it when deciding whether the siting was acceptable.
DM7(1) says planners should assume other regulatory regimes operate effectively unless there is clear evidence to the contrary. It also recognises that matters covered by those regimes can be material to a planning decision where they have land-use implications. Neil and Karen argue that councils must weigh and reconcile the evidence for the particular site and decide whether public-health conditions are needed under Annex I(B)(3) of the European Electronic Communications Code (EECC). They want the government to give councils the clear guidance and access to technical expertise they need to carry out that responsibility.
In Thomas v Cheltenham Borough Council, Lady Justice Andrews described the European Electronic Communications Code as part of retained EU law and included it in the legal framework for deciding where a mast could go. In Neil and Karen’s case, the High Court refused permission to proceed, holding that the claim was out of time and that the Directive could not be relied on directly in English law in the way they argued. Lady Justice Falk refused permission to appeal. Neil and Karen say this leaves their central question unresolved: how should councils give effect to the Code’s public-health provisions when deciding whether a particular mast location is acceptable?
The government has yet to answer the points Neil and Karen raised in its planning and deregulation consultations. Communities continue to face these questions mast by mast, as Thomas Way shows.
The chronology starts back in September 2023
21 December 2020. The UK transposed the European Electronic Communications Code (EECC). Our later challenge concerned how the government implemented the coded public-health protections and what local authorities were required to do in practice.
2021–2022 Campaign correspondence documented differing positions on local authorities’ EECC responsibilities. Ofcom said it had no role in planning approval or reviewing ICNIRP assessments used in planning. Mendip recognised a role for local planning authorities when exercising their planning functions. Solihull sought clarification from government.
13 September 2023. We sent a letter before claim and detailed submission to the relevant government departments. This relied on Schedule 8, paragraph 39(5) of the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018 and sought administrative remedies to give effect to the EECC’s public-health provisions. The extended reply deadline was 3 November 2023.
20 December 2023. We filed the judicial review application in the Administrative Court, AC-2023-LON-003728.
26 April 2024. HHJ Jarman KC refused permission for judicial review and certified the claim as totally without merit. The court treated the claim as out of time and rejected the way it relied on the Directive. The certification prevented an oral renewal in the High Court.
6 May–18 June 2024. We sought permission to appeal and made submissions on 10 and 31 May arguing that Aarhus costs protection should apply. On 18 June, District Judge Obi made a costs order of £36,794 in favour of the defendants and interested party.
31 July–19 December 2024. Lady Justice Falk refused permission to appeal on the papers on 31 July. She refused the first application to reopen on 31 October and the second on 19 December, certifying the second as totally without merit.
22 January–7 February 2025. We applied for an incompatibility order under section 6D of the Withdrawal Act, clarification of the Schedule 8 provisions and a stay of the previous orders. On 24 January, Master Bancroft-Rimmer said the Court of Appeal could not deal with the application because there were no live proceedings. Lord Justice Dingemans upheld that direction on 7 February.
24–26 February 2025 We asked the Court of Appeal for permission to take the constitutional and jurisdictional issues to the Supreme Court. The Court of Appeal replied that there was no further right of appeal in those circumstances.
13 March 2025. In the separate Cheltenham case, Thomas v Cheltenham Borough Council [2025] EWCA Civ 259, Lady Justice Andrews described the EECC as part of retained EU law in her outline of the legal framework for a mast-siting dispute.
25 April–4 July 2025 We applied to the Supreme Court, UKSC/2025/0071. It refused permission, giving lateness and lack of merit as reasons, and ordered costs for resisting the application, to be assessed if not agreed.
26 November 2025–18 April 2026. REULA: We returned to government with a formal submission under section 7 of the Retained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Act 2023. We followed up on 14 January, made a further submission on 17 February, and requested clarification on 18 April 2026
28–29 May 2026. DHSC declined to pursue our request, relied on the previous court decisions and reiterated that Ofcom is the sole designated telecoms national regulatory authority. DSIT confirmed on 29 May that it had referred the correspondence to DHSC.
25 August 2026 We filed our application with the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR).